Analysis: The return of conference realignment and 12 questions facing the Big 12 (2022)

ByTim Fitzgerald

  • Edit
  • Slot to 247Sports Home
  • Slot to Kansas State Wildcats Newsletter

Just when it seemed as if there would be a brief respite from college conference expansion and realignment, the Big Ten raided the Pac-12 of two of its biggest jewels: USC and UCLA. And that might not be the biggest news to emerge from Thursday’s stunning breaking news.

In some ways, what the Big Ten pulled off Thursday is even bigger than last July’s news of Oklahoma and Texas leaving the Big 12 for the SEC. At least that made regional sense. The Big Ten will now stretch from Jersey to Southern California. The nearest school to USC and UCLA would be in Lincoln, Nebraska. That means that the Big Ten is almost assuredly not done with expansion.

If this expansion holds up, both the SEC and Big Ten will be at 16 members. Thus, another reason this news feels more significant than last summer’s is that it seems to be an indication that both conferences appear headed beyond 16 with 20 being the likely number for both in a new post-NCAA super conference environment.

Oddly, the Big 12 may be the most insulated from further raiding of its members. The Pac-12 better have one heck of a backup plan, or at least two more significant members — Oregon and Washington — will also be headed to the Big Ten. And sorry ACC, that media rights contract won’t seem so ironclad with the SEC and Big Ten begin fighting over the best of the rest. North Carolina, Virginia, Clemson, and Florida State would all be giant gets for either conference.

It's also probably time for Notre Dame to pick a conference. Of course, the best fit is in the Big Ten and that addition would be a clear indication that the end goal isn't 16 members for the conference. The Irish, though, are such a big player that joining the ACC along with one other school — the Big 12's West Virginia continues to make sense — could insulatethe ACC from Big Ten and SEC raids.

Outside of Kansas and Iowa State dreaming of Big Ten membership — thoughts that seem greatly diminished by this Pacific time zone grab — the rest of the Big 12 seems immune to further expansion by the Big Ten or SEC. (Unless those leagues are eying more than 20 members apiece.)

It also creates a new environment for incoming Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark to navigate. It suddenly doesn’t seem like a coincidence that the Big 12 announced its new boss one day before the LA bomb was dropped on college athletics.

Yormark carries a reputation as a hard charger, a guy who gets things done and isn’t bound by conventional thinking. That is exactly what the Big 12 needs as it looks to the future and its own possible expansion beyond the 12 members that will exist after OU and UT leave.

Behind the scenes, the Big 12 has been eying the Pac-12 since it added BYU, Cincinnati, UCF and Houston last fall. All four will now join the Big 12 in 2023, whether the Sooners and Longhorns stay or go prior to their scheduled departure in 2025.

Now the Pac-12 is in play, but so too might be the ACC if the Big Ten and SEC wage a two-front attack on the mostly basketball-first ACC. Even if raided, the ACC would offer the Big 12 or Big 16 or Big 20 a chance to pick up really tantalizing pieces for the new, growing Eastern wing of the conference. For example, beyond schools such as North Carolina and Virginia, would Virginia Tech, Georgia Tech, North Carolina State or Miami be on the wish list of the two most powerful conferences? Maybe, but not all, and those and other ACC members would look great when added to West Virginia, Cincinnati and UCF.

The first step for Yormack is to look West, though, The league solved its WVU-island issue with additions last summer but created a BYU-island problem in the process. So, adding at least three Pac-12 schools to a Western scheduling pod seems like an obvious move. Picking up one more Eastern school to get to 16 also seems likely but there are many ways to go about this.

(Video) The Big 12 is Still the Hunter as Conference Realignment Continues | Realignment | Mack Rhoades

There are a lot of questions surrounding the future of the Big 12, and college athletics (actually football is what counts in this discussion) so let’s address some of those issues.

Sign up for GoPowercat VIP access and get your first month for just $1!

The Big 12 finds itself in an unfamiliar position. It is the hunter and not the hunted. The decision of Pac-12 commissioner George Kliavkoff to not invite Big 12 members to join the league last summer may prove foolish. Oklahoma State, Texas Tech, and two other Big 12 schools would have leaped off the burning wreckage of the Big 12 11 months ago, but now the Big 12 feels as solid and sturdy as it has since the first waves of realignment swept away Nebraska (Big Ten), Colorado (Pac-12), Texas A&M and Missouri (SEC).

The new Big 12 has a sense of confidence that a boxer finds after being rocked in the early round but is still trading punches in the 10th round. Yormack brings a new burst of energy to the conference and the Big 12 may be posed to launch some haymakers at the Pac-12.

The answer to this question starts with the future of Oregon and Washington, the Pac-12’s most desirable programs not located in Los Angeles. If youare the Big 12 Conference, you have to be concerned that they would accept a quick invite while planning to bolt for the Big Ten at first chance. Honestly, that’s a pretty good plan if you’re at either of those schools.

From geographical and cultural perspectives, the remaining members of the Pac-12 South —Utah, Colorado, Arizona and Arizona State — make the most sense. Ironically, the most-likely Pac-12 school to get a quick Big 12 invite would be the youngest in terms of membership and Power 5 standing: Utah. Adding the Utes gives BYU a natural rival.

Furthermore, the Big 12 seems like a logical fit for the Arizona schools since the conference already features five schools from what would also be considered the geographical Southwest. But do those schools move the needle in terms of TV and fan support? And would the Big 12 invite Colorado to rejoin after it previously betrayed the conference?

And unless the Big 12 invites more than four Pac-12 schools —in a Big 16 scenario with four Pac-12 additions would likely move Houston to the east scheduling pod — northern California members Stanford and Cal seem poor fits for the Big 12 and Oregon State and Washington State don’t seem to move the needle much.

Talk continues on KU message boards that an invite to the Big Ten is imminent, but that now seems even more laughable than before the USC and UCLA invites. However, KU being added to the Big Ten isn’t unthinkable for two reasons: 1. KU carries AAU academic standing so valued by the Big Ten and 2. Someone needs to lose the football games in an expanded Big Ten, so at least it could be a school that brings basketball value, which doesn’t mean a lot to conference media rights deals.

(Video) LIVE: Latest From Pac 12 - TV Deal May Only Be $30 Million/Team | Would Houston Leave?

The other scenario is the Big 12 is sluggish as the ACC is raided and looks to reload, poaching the conference’s three Eastern schools: West Virginia, Cincinnati and UCF.

If Kansas or a current Big 12 member would leave, it likely means the conference would invite another current Pac-12 member, but other western schools such as Boise or San Diego State bring value too. And if the ACC steals the Big 12’s eastern flank, then a full-on Pac-12/Big 12 merger is on.

The biggest question here is what is the end goal of the Big Ten and SEC? If it is to get to 20 members, then the Big 12 is mostly safe. But if they're going to 24, then this could turn into chaos.

Want the latestKansas Stateheadlines sent to your inbox?Click to sign up for GoPowercat's daily newsletter!

They can try but there is absolutely no reason for the likes of Oklahoma State, Texas Tech, or anyone else to leave the stability of the Big 12 — that's a remarkable phrase considering the reality of 11 months ago — to leap into a conference with a plethora of issues that includes limited TV value and certain fan bases that are nothing like those in the fan-first Big 12. The best plan for the Pac-12 is to identify two schools that its remaining members will accept athletically and academically and invite them into an even further weakened Pac-12.

The issues that have faced the Big 12 in the past, most importantly being exposed to regional raids from multiple conferences, is the same problem now facing the ACC. Aside from the Big Ten and SEC sharing borders or states with key ACC members, now Big 12 expansion brought it in contact with ACC schools. The Pac-12 meanwhile is isolated in its ability to attract new members, certainly when the academic demands of some current members are calculated into the equation.

It seems unfathomable that the Big Ten is going to add two schools from Los Angeles and call it good. It seems almost certain that the conference would also want Oregon and Washington — all four of those schools carry AAU status — but those additions come with the added political fallout from supporters of Oregon State and Washington State. That gets a lot muckier almost immediately.

It’s also hard to imagine the Big Ten (and as mentioned the SEC) won’t test the ACC’s media rights agreement because the University of North Carolinais acrown jewel of conference expansion. Notre Dame probably ranks ahead of UNC on everyone's wish list, so what are the Irish going to do now?

Again, getting to 20 for the Big Ten and SEC may not impact the new Big 12 much but if they move to 24 each, all of the Power 5 as we now know it will be destroyed. That seems sad and unfortunate.

This is a great question if the ultimate plan is for the Big Ten and SEC to form a level of football above the current Power 5. Schools left behind in the remnants of the former Power 5 might be tempted by the money and exposure that comes with playing schools from the two super conferences, but if these conferences envision paying players and completely abandoning the amateur model, such scheduling would also be foolhardy.

No, the Big 12 and those schools still competed in the gutted FBS level of play would be wise to ban all FBS schools from scheduling games with these professional or semi-professional leagues. The end result is the members of the Big Ten and SEC would only play against themselves, thus resulting in an average record of 6-6 for all members.

When schools that are accustomed to winning start losing for years on end, fans will not be happy. Nebraska fans are loyal and persistent, but the Huskers might want to start winning again or that school’s move to the Big Ten, let alone the mega-sized Big Ten, will look like a disastrous decision.

Follow @GoPowercat on Twitter

(Video) Explaining Why The Big 12 NEEDS To Expand West

Probably not, but if it was, what a huge break for the Big 12. Not only did the conference know who its new leader would be, but Yormark’s reputation strengthens the outlook of the Big 12. He is regarded as a strong leader who doesn't miss details and is like a shark, always in motion.

There are two problems with Pac-12 expansion. One, it is somewhat limited by geography, and, two, its academic standards would preclude some of those schools, most notably UNLV and Boise, from being invited to the Pac-12.

Stanford and Cal don’t want to be affiliated with schools they view as glorified junior colleges.

When the Big 12 was formed in 1996 by merging the Big Eight with four former members of the Southwest Conference — the Pac-12 may want to look at the history of the SWC and understand why it died despite regional importance — it also apparently trademarked the Big 14 and Big 16 names. Now, if those trademarks are still in place is a good question. Still, it sure feels like since the day the league began to explore expansion after the announced departure of OU and Texas, the league has left the door wide open to expanding beyond 12 if the right members presented themselves.

Now they have.

What's hard to explain is this apparent push beyond 16 to 20 by both the SEC and Big Ten. A grouping of 20 schools isn't really a conference. It's two 10-school conferences, or four five-school conferences, under one heading. With 20 members, how often would one play all of its fellow members in football? Not very often, if ever. That sure doesn't seem like a conference.

(Video) The Big 12 is open for business and the Blue Chip Ratio predicts another Alabama national title

At 16, however, by grouping members in four scheduling pods of four, every school would play every other member school in a home-and-home football series every six years if the league is playing nine conference games. That is sustainable andwould provide scheduling variety whilefacing every other conference member in a reasonable timeframe.

Sign up for GoPowercat VIP access and get your first month for just $1!

That entire “Alliance” thing was silly, reactive, and somewhat childish because we all knew money would talk the loudest, and now it seems as if the Big Ten and SEC are joined at the hip in destroying college athletics as we know it. It seems like it will be great for them, but never forget that someone has to lose the games so a lot of schools that want to be great won’t have much of a chance at being much above average.

The harsh truth is yes. If someone can explain to me a viable plan for the remaining members of this version of the Big 12 to have access to membership in either a Big Ten or SEC super-conference, then I will listen. I don’t think there is one, which means the most palatable plan is for the remaining schools to bolster their standing and make the most out of the situation.

All indications are that the new super conferences will exist outside of the realm of NCAA football, which means being the best of those schools still playing amateur college football will be tangible for schools such as Kansas State.

Ask yourself this: Would you prefer your college football team to win 10 or more games and play for hardware, orwin five or fewer games and play for much larger paychecks?

It’s time for the Big 12 to do something it has never done: Get aggressive. I think the largest a conference can be to actually be a conference is 16, so get to 16 with the best possible members available right now. If the SEC and Big Ten go to 20 or 24, they will essentially be two 10- or 12-school conferences under one umbrella. You will rarely if ever, play teams within your own conference.

The Big 12 has been confident for a while that this was coming for the Pac-12 so it’s hard to believe a plan isn’t in place for getting to 16, but it’s also the often-passive Big 12 we’re talking about.

Adding four Pac-12 members right now and becoming a coast-to-coast conference offering broadcast and streaming media partners inventory in every available time slot for college sports seems like a viable plan. Playing up that you are college football as it was intended is also a strong marketing ploy because there will be tremendous pushback against those conferences decimating college athletics as we know it.

The Big 12 needs to be concerned about the Big 12. Go hurt some feelings. Go get some members. And understand that for once, the Big 12 is in a position to win at the expansion/realignment game.

(Video) College Football Playoff expansion, conference alignment, NIL: Everything AAC commissioner Mike

Make sure you subscribe tothe Powercat Podcastat your favorite podcast provider, includingApple,SpotifyorAmazon.

">247Sports

FAQs

Is the Big 12 still power 5? ›

However, five of the six former AQ conferences are now known as the "Power Five conferences": the Big Ten Conference, the Big 12 Conference, the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC), the Pac-12 Conference, and the Southeastern Conference (SEC).

Why did Nebraska leave the Big 12? ›

A desire for stability in athletics was the primary motivation that led the University of Nebraska-Lincoln to leave the Big 12 to join the Big Ten. At the time of the University' s decision to join the Big Ten, the Big 12 was extremely unstable in terms of its membership.

Will Big 12 expand again? ›

The Big 12 is already scheduled to expand to 12 members by the 2023 college football season after announcing it would add BYU, Houston, Cincinnati, and UCF. That move came after the league lost football powerhouses Texas and Oklahoma, who announced they will join the SEC, likely in 2025.

Will Notre Dame join the Big Ten? ›

Notre Dame football remains independent but competes in the ACC in other sports. The Big Ten has invited Notre Dame to join, but the university declined. Without a conference affiliation, Notre Dame risks becoming marginalized and losing millions in media revenue.

How much does the Big 12 pay each school? ›

IRVING, TX — The Big 12 Conference will distribute a record $426 million to its 10 member institutions this year, an average of about $42.6 million per school.

Will Big 12 remain a power conference? ›

For the moment, it looks like the Big 12 will remain a Power Five league, though one with only eight of its original members. Those eight have stuck together long enough for a realignment lifesaver to come their way.

Why are Texas and Oklahoma leaving the Big 12? ›

The news that both the Oklahoma Sooners and Texas Longhorns would be leaving the Big 12 for the SEC was earth-shattering for two reasons: it made the SEC out as what would ruin college football for certain, and it made the future of the Big 12 painfully uncertain.

Why did Texas A&M leave Big 12? ›

Nebraska, Missouri, Texas A&M and Colorado elected to leave the Big 12 because of frustration with Texas. If those schools remained in the league, the Big 12 wouldn't be so far behind in the conference race. But why did those schools leave? It's not because Colorado's culture just aligned more with Washington State.

Is Missouri going back to the Big 12? ›

Missouri will now join Iowa State, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and West Virginia along with affiliate programs Air Force, Northern Colorado, North Dakota State, Northern Iowa, South Dakota State, Utah Valley and Wyoming to form the new Big 12 of wrestling. This move takes place effective July 1, 2021.

What year does the Big 12 expand? ›

The Big 12 made headlines last offseason when Texas and Oklahoma jointly announced their intent to leave the conference in favor of the SEC. In a corresponding move, the Big 12 added BYU, Central Florida, Cincinnati and Houston — all of whom are set to join on July 1, 2023.

What 4 teams are being added to the Big 12? ›

That left the the prospect of the Big 12 having just eight active members, but the conference moved quickly to add Houston, BYU, Cincinnati and Central Florida to its ranks no later than July 1, 2024.

What teams will move to the Big 12? ›

BYU, Cincinnati, Houston and UCF are set to join the Big 12 in 2023. The latter three schools finalized their buyout with the American Athletic Conference on June 10 to officially join next July, timing that looks astute now that realignment is churning again.

Why doesn t Nd join a conference? ›

For everything that changed Thursday, the reasons for Notre Dame to join a conference really have not. The school needs access to the national championship. It needs a home for its Olympic sports. It needs a broadcast partner.

Will the SEC expand to 16 teams? ›

We're positioned at 16 (teams) for a robust future,” an SEC athletic director told SDS. “The need just isn't there.” Potential future moves on the expansion front could change that “need,” two SEC sources say, but conference presidents believe the SEC is positioned well for the future growth of college football.

How much does Notre Dame get from NBC? ›

Notre Dame would remain independent if it can earn at least $75 million annually in media rights revenue from current broadcast partner NBC, sources told CBS Sports. The Fighting Irish's deal with the network is set to expire in 2025.

Which NCAA conferences make the most money? ›

More financial figures from Power 5 conferences have been released, and the SEC once again is at the top of the heap in terms of revenue. The ACC joined the SEC as the only Power 5 conferences to show revenue increases for the corresponding 2021 fiscal year, new federal tax records show, USA Today reported.

Who will be the new Big 12 commissioner? ›

Fox Sports CEO and Executive Producer, Eric Shanks:

“On behalf of FOX Sports, we'd like to officially congratulate Brett Yormark on being named the new Commissioner of the Big 12,” said Eric Shanks, CEO and Executive Producer of FOX Sports.

How much money does each school get from the Big Ten Network? ›

The conference reported a 35.7% drop in revenue from the 2019-20 fiscal year to 2020-21 and distributed just $19.8 million to each school. The Big Ten fell by 11.6% but still distributed $47.8 million for each school. The Big Ten's 2017 media rights deal produced an average of $441.7 million in TV revenue a year.

How good is the Big 12 Conference? ›

The Sagarin ratings agree with ESPN's analysis as well. The Big 12 currently leads all conferences with an 82.58 simple average, while the SEC had an 81.45. So if Alabama wins the BCS Championship, does that mean the SEC is the best conference? No.

What will happen to Big 12? ›

BYU Athletics Director Tom Holmoe said during Friday's press conference that the Big 12 will split into two football divisions as the conference returns to 12 teams.

Who is leaving the Big 12? ›

Texas and Oklahoma are set to leave the Big 12 for the SEC no later than 2025. For now, the two programs might be playing in a 14-team conference rather than the usual 10-team conference of the past.

How much does OU pay for leaving the Big 12? ›

According to Brown, “Multiple sources told Horns247 this week, as of right now, Oklahoma isn't as financially flexible as Texas is when it comes to having to pay the roughly $80 million in exit fees. “Money won't have any influence on when Texas would decide to leave for the SEC,” one high-ranking UT source said.

When did A&M leave the Big 12? ›

A&M announced on August 31, 2011 that it would leave the Big 12 in June 2012 to join the SEC, but the invitation process was prolonged by various moves by the Big 12, which feared that A&M's departure would scuttle the conference.

Will Texas A&M leave SEC? ›

To those who may not know, the under-performing Texas A&M Aggies are leaving to the SEC, and will be the only Texas school that will not play other Texas schools each year. This radical decision by Texas A&M cannot be easily explained, and the choice likely had many different factors involved (at least, I hope).

Can A&M block Texas from joining SEC? ›

Still, A&M doesn't want the Longhorns in their conference, and the Aggies do have an avenue to stop it. Any additions to the conference require a three-quarters vote (11 out of 14) of current SEC members, meaning the Aggies just need to convince three other schools to go along with Operation Horns Down.

Who has more money Texas or Texas A&M? ›

When it comes to value, the Texas A&M Aggies are matched only by the Texas Longhorns, according to GoBankingRates averages posted by Fox Sports on Monday night. Both football programs shared the No. 1 spot in the ratings, with an estimated annual value of $147 million.

Is A&M or UT better? ›

The University of Texas at Austin is a much better academic institution than Texas A&M University. UT is ranked No. 52 in U.S. News' National University rankings, while A&M is No. 70.

Why did the SEC want Missouri? ›

Not only does TV marketability play a role in the money-making factor for a school, but so does successful academics. The high standards Missouri places on its players helps the school to with more money from research grants and other donations that, in turn, would help the value and reputation of the SEC.

When did Nebraska and Colorado leave the Big 12? ›

As the Big 12, it was split into two six-team divisions, one of which consisted of the two Oklahoma and four Texas schools. The conference's structure changed again when it was announced in 2010 that Colorado was departing to join the Pacific-12 Conference and that Nebraska was leaving to join the Big Ten Conference.

Why did Missouri go to SEC? ›

The question now is whether SEC teams will now play nine conference games instead of eight. While putting Missouri in the SEC East had a lot to do with preserving current rivalries, it also makes them the best candidate to move to the SEC West if the conference ever goes to 16 teams in the future.

Why is it called the Big 12? ›

On February 25, 1994, it was announced that a new conference would be formed from the members of the Big Eight and four of the Texas member colleges of the Southwest Conference. Though the name would not be made official for several months, newspaper accounts immediately dubbed the new entity the "Big 12".

Is USC going to the Big 10? ›

USC helped kick off the latest phase of college football realignment by announcing it will join the Big Ten in 2024, along with UCLA. And while everybody knows it's about money, the thing that really inspired USC to make the move was just how little it was getting compared to other schools.

Is Texas Tech staying in the Big 12? ›

For now, everyone is happy since Texas decided to stay at home in the Big-12. Fans of the Big-12 will still have the Red River Shootout between Oklahoma and Texas, the Texas vs.

Is Cincinnati going to the Big Twelve? ›

Cincinnati, Houston and UCF will officially join the Big 12 on July 1, 2023, after reaching an exit agreement with the American Athletic Conference, the league and schools announced Friday.

Is Cincinnati going to the Big 12 Conference? ›

CINCINNATI – The University of Cincinnati will officially enter the Big 12 as a conference member on July 1, 2023. The Big 12 announced on Sept.

How will New Big 12 be divided? ›

Big 12 engaged in plans to split into two seven-team divisions beginning in 2023 amid realignment. The Big 12 is engaged in plans to split into two seven-team divisions in football beginning in 2023 to temporarily restructure as a 14-team league as the realignment process unfolds, league sources tell CBS Sports.

Is Kansas staying in the Big 12? ›

Officials with the Big 12 Conference announced Friday that the Big 12 Basketball Tournament will remain in Kansas City with a new two-year extension. That means Kansas City will remain the host site for the Phillips 66 Men's and Women's Basketball Championships through at least 2027.

Where are Oklahoma and Texas going? ›

On July 21, news broke via the Houston Chronicle that the Universities of Oklahoma and Texas would move their athletic departments from the Big 12 to the Southeastern Conference. The decision set off a nuclear reaction inside the Big 12 offices.

What will happen to Big 12? ›

The Big 12 is operating under the assumption that both the Longhorns and Sooners will stay in the league four more years. The current Big 12 television contract with Fox and ESPN ends in 2025.

What are the Big 12 basketball standings? ›

Standings
SchoolBig 12Overall
Oklahoma State8-1015-15
Iowa State7-1122-13
Oklahoma7-1119-16
Kansas State6-1214-17
6 more rows

Is Oklahoma University still in the Big 12? ›

Oklahoma and Texas announced late last summer that they were leaving the Big 12 to become members of the Southeastern Conference. Since that announcement, the Big 12 has come to agreement with four new schools to join the conference as early as the 2023 season.

What teams are the Big 12 adding? ›

The four teams that the Big 12 added were the UCF Knights, BYU Cougars, Houston Cougars, and Cincinnati Bearcats.

Videos

1. David Nixon on BYUSN 07.18.22
(BYU Sports Nation)
2. The Big Ten Will NEVER Be the Same | Bigger Ten #098
(Michigan Podcast)
3. Heisman Trophy Picks + Phil Steele Interview - College Football Predictions
(Sports Gambling Podcast)
4. NBER SI 2022 Gender in the Economy: Change and Persistence of Norms
(NBER)
5. If These Moments Were Not Filmed, No One Would Believe It!
(Top 5 Best)
6. "Putin is Pushing Our Buttons", Fiona Hill on Russia's War in Ukraine
(Intelligence Squared)

Top Articles

You might also like

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Last Updated: 10/30/2022

Views: 5776

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Birthday: 1992-02-16

Address: Suite 851 78549 Lubowitz Well, Wardside, TX 98080-8615

Phone: +67618977178100

Job: Manufacturing Director

Hobby: Running, Mountaineering, Inline skating, Writing, Baton twirling, Computer programming, Stone skipping

Introduction: My name is Wyatt Volkman LLD, I am a handsome, rich, comfortable, lively, zealous, graceful, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.